Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven Consumer Reports for 2021 – Buyer’s Guide & Reviews

The charm of buying and using an air fryer toaster oven is as varied as the settings in one. You can do way more in the Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven than a convection oven. Plus, the former is at least 5 times more efficient and longer lasting.

So if you think you’re paying extra, you’re wrong because an air fryer toaster oven combines toasting, air frying, baking, warming, broiling, grilling, and roasting all in one. Traditionally, you would have needed to buy at least 3 separate kitchen appliances to do what a single air fry toaster oven can now do.

Now that you’ve made up your mind, here’s my quick recommendation: the COSORI CO130-AO. It’s efficient, dependable, and worth the value. If you’ve never used an Air Fryer Toaster Oven before, I suggest you start with this one.

Top 6 Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven Consumer Reports in 2021 Reviews

The reviews you see below are based on my personal preferences which I’m assuming most people share. It’s important to look beyond the fancy features of a kitchen appliance and ask yourself in what way would a product like this improve your cooking skills.

1. Cosori co130-ao air fryer toaster oven combo

• 12-in-1 Presets: Pizza, Roast, Airfry, Toast, Bagel, Bake, Broil, Cookies, Rotisserie, Dehydrate, Ferment and Keep Warm
• Air Fryer: Enjoy air fried meals with up to 85% less fat than traditionally fried foods. Air fry feature may require more cooking time than standalone air fryers
• Large Capacity: Easily fit 6 slices of toast, a 13 inch pizza, or an entire chicken in the 32qt/30L oven
• Thoughtful Design: Enjoy easy cooking with the crisp LED screen, convenient dial controls, and interior light
• Recipes & Accessories: Check out the included recipe book, crumb tray, fry basket, food tray, wire rack, rotisserie fork set, and rotisserie handle for more cooking options

Finally something that does the job of an air fryer, toaster, and oven. The COSORI CO130-AO is a household favorite everywhere. It has many pre-set settings and intuitive control with tons of helpful buttons.

Large capacity

There might even be some room left to roast some potatoes with the chicken inside. It’s so spacious and dynamic to use. It does boast of a 30 L capacity for air frying, grilling, toasting, dehydrating, re-heating, and so on.

Programmed Cooking Functions

I don’t know if this happens with you too but whenever I’m in a hurry to make something I often mix up the temperature settings. That is why I always appreciate a kitchen appliance that comes with preset functions – the way COSORI does.

The long list of cooking functions (up to 12) is really tempting to see on the panel. It just reminds me that this little beast can do so much more than standard oven combos.

It comes with a bunch of accessories that complete its sleek and large design. Capable of fitting up to 6 toast slices, a 13-inch pizza, and a full chicken/turkey/steak easily.

It can air fry, toast, warm, ferment, bake, roast, grill, broil, rotisserie, dehydrate, and a few others. You can do practically anything as long as you have the right ingredients.

During cooking, the settings are laid out perfectly for you. You can even use the oven back to back and the exterior frame won’t heat up. It’s a rare find that is as versatile as it performs – and that says a lot!

Pros

• Interior light with LCD display for nighttime.
• Easy timer and temperature dial for quick use.
• Powerful, compact, and durable design.

Cons

• The crumb tray isn’t deep enough to stay clean.
• The air fry basket is small in size.

2. Cuisinart toa-65 digital convection oven

• Specially engineered 1800-watt motor, fan and heater deliver high-velocity, high-heat airflow for perfectly fried results with minimal noise
• Wide range of toaster oven functions: bake, broil, pizza, roast, toast, bagel, reheat, Warm, dual cook
• Low temperature setting to slow cook, braise and more. Plus, dedicated functions for dehydrating and proofing
• Air fry function and presets take the guesswork out of frying wings, fries, nuggets, snacks and veggies
• More options to customize your cooking include: wide temperature range: 80°f to 450°f; adjustable time with preset ranges for each function; defrost and high/low convection fan speed options

If you never have too much on your hands to cook up a delicious meal, using a digital convection oven can prove useful. But it won’t do if it’s not fast and powerful enough. Thankfully, you don’t have to wait around for the Cuisinart TOA-65.

The Cuisinart TOA-65 Air Fryer toaster oven a part of this Toasters & Toaster Ovens evaluation program in Consumer Reports.

Powerful motor

The Cuisinart produces better results because it is equipped with a high-intensity fan and heater motor. It’s relatively quieter and energy-efficient. And it gets the job done in reduced time and no mess.

You can customize all the cooking by temperature and time. But if you need some assistance, it also features preset cooking programs for you to quickly select and follow.

The digital display, push button and dial controls, and the convenient but not too small size make the Cuisinart an intelligent pick.

Non-stick interior & parts

Though you may not consider this next bit, it’s important if you use an oven on a regular basis. And that is cleaning. Cleanup can be exhausting if you use a not-so-great oven at home. It gets greasy, sticky, and all kinds of dirty very soon.

The Cuisinart TOA-65 has non-stick surfaces on the inside. Including the baking pan and air frying basket it boasts of. In fact, these parts are dishwasher-safe.

The convenient pull-out crumb tray is sturdy and deep enough to maintain a clean environment. You can quickly scrub out the burnt food crumbs on the tray’s surface with mild soap and a damp cloth. No hard scrubbing or pre-soaking the oven rack or tray. It cleans up fairly quickly and effortlessly.

Pros

• All the default settings are accurate and effective.
• Intuitive and versatile controls.
• Powerful and fast with a sleek design.

Cons

• It does rank low in user satisfaction.
• The fan makes a grinding noise every now and ten.

3. Breville bov900bssusc the smart toaster oven

• SALEBreville BOV900BSSUSC The Smart Toaster Oven, 17.2′ x 21.4′ x 12.8′, Brushed Stainless Steel
• Breville BOV900BSSUSC The Smart Toaster Oven, 17.2″ x 21.4″ x 12.8″, Brushed Stainless Steel
• The Breville Smart Oven Air with Element iQ System is a versatile countertop oven allowing you to roast, air fry and dehydrate; Use super convection to reduce cooking time by up to 30% and choose from 13 cooking functions; Includes an interior oven light
• ELEMENT iQ SYSTEM: Using 6 independent quartz elements, smart algorithms steer power to where and when it’s needed to create the ideal cooking environment; Sensing and digital PID temperature control eliminates cold spots for precise and even cooking
• AIR FRY & DEHYDRATE SETTINGS: Air fry French fries and other family favorites; Higher temperatures combined with super convection (maximized air flow) deliver crispy golden air fried foods; Dehydrate a wide range of food, up to 4 trays of goodness at once
• SUPER CONVECTION TECHNOLOGY: 2 speed convection fan (super & regular) offers greater cooking control; Super convection provides a greater volume of hot air to ensure fast and even heat distribution perfect for air frying, dehydration and roasting
• 13 COOKING FUNCTIONS: Super versatile countertop oven and air fryer with 13 functions to guide you to perfection: Toast, Bagel, Broil, Bake, Roast, Warm, Pizza, Proof, Air Fry, Reheat, Cookies, Slow Cook and Dehydrate

Is it enough to say that once you buy a smart toaster oven like this one, you’re keeping it for life? Only a few kitchen appliances exceed expectations. And Breville The Smart Toaster Oven does on every level. It’s efficient, intelligent, and multi-functional. Here are some of its best features that I loved.

The ‘Smart’ Features

So what’s so smart about this air fryer toaster oven anyway? For starters, the Breville does everything a toaster, air fryer, baking oven, grill, breadmaker, and microwave can do. And then some.

It’s a convection air fryer which means it is 100% energy efficient and fast. It features an entire catalogue of useful cooking functions with preset temperature and time settings. You can adjust these variables as well, if you want.

The innovative Element iQ system is one of the kind. And I say one of a kind because I’ve used a lot of toaster ovens before. And none compare to this one.

The dual speed fan increases the volume of hot air using the same amount of energy as one. This saves time in cooking up extensive dishes. And it saves your power bill even if you use it daily.

User-friendly Features

The interior light and large space makes this toaster oven one of the most practical purchases of mine. Besides the 13 pre-set cooking functions, it’s so much faster to use this machine than it is to use a standard oven.

The high temperature settings can be easily adjusted with the dial. The timer dial is positioned underneath the temperature dial. Since both settings are not interlinked in a single dial, this makes adjusting on the go very easy and straightforward.

And I like having the extra room for accessibility because I have a habit of doing things in a rush but organized manner. So the additional features, smart cooking, and sturdy parts complement that.

Pros

• Automatic heating with no preheating required.
• Accurate and stable temperature/time settings.
• Includes a pizza pan, broil rack, roasting pan, oven racks, and mesh basket rack.

Cons

• It is a bulky and heavy toaster oven.
• Allow some room at the back to prevent overheating.

4. Black + decker to3265xssd extra wide air fry toaster oven

• SALEBlack+Decker TO3265XSSD Extra Wide Crisp ‘N Bake Air Fry Toaster Oven, Silver, Fits 9′ x 13′ Pan
• Black+Decker TO3265XSSD Extra Wide Crisp ‘N Bake Air Fry Toaster Oven, Silver, Fits 9″ x 13″ Pan
• Air Fry Technology: Deep fried taste without the fat! This innovative cooking method surrounds food with high intensity hot air to bake, brown, and crisp your favorite foods using little to no oil.
• 5 Cooking Functions: Choose from five available cooking methods: bake, broil, toast, keep warm, and air fry.
• Extra Large Capacity: Cook for the whole family! This large capacity toaster oven fits a 9” x 13” pan with handles, 8 slices of bread, or a 12” pizza.
• Countertop Baking: The Bake function and extra wide capacity let you make pizzas, brownies, casseroles, and so much more! Plus, it’s great for reheating leftovers without turning on the big oven.
• 60-minute Timer: The 60-minute precision timer is convenient for short and long cooking tasks.

The Black + Decker Air Fry Toaster Oven is like the COSORI CO130-AO in many ways. Mostly because it’s large in size and is perfect as a countertop toaster oven. It may not offer as many cooking functions which is a letdown but it makes up for that in performance and value.

Wide design

Anyone who uses this toaster oven finds its broad and spacious design very forgiving and considerable. The large capacity is a life-saver because it allows you to cook more in reduced time.

It’s the perfect addition for countertop cooking. And since it’s wider than it is bulkier, it takes up less height so it can easily fit under cabinet spaces and in corners.

Having an appliance like this tucked away but still noticeable on your countertop is a blessing. And speaking of things that improve life, the pull-out rack and air fry basket are sturdily built to make food as light as fries to roast chicken or meat.

Having said that, I highly recommend this to anyone who has limited counter space.

Fast performance

The efficacy of this best air fryer toaster oven extends to its functionality as well. It features 5 cooking functions that are straightforward and convenient to access. The control board has three dials that lets you control everything. The cooking functions, temperature, and time.

Beside the temperature variable, you’ll also find which cooking function is relevant to choose. And on the plus side, for toasting, you have precise controls that let you toast the bread crispier if you want it that way.

The fast performance of this appliance sort of shines through because it’s one of the quietest air fry toaster ovens on this list. The fan hardly makes a sound. You don’t even have to place this in an open space because there’s no chance that it heats up during consistent use.

Pros

• It makes food warm really fast and perfectly.
• Air frying is the best and most powerful feature.
• Toasts evenly without making a mess.

Cons

• The controls aren’t that versatile.

5. Cuisinart toa-60 convection toaster oven airfryer

• Cuisinart TOA-60 Convection Toaster Oven Airfryer, Silver
• 1800-Watts with 7 functions: air fry, convection bake, convection broil, bake, broil, Warm, toast
• 0. 6 cubic foot non-stick interior with oven light. Dimensions (L x W x H): 15. 50 x 16. 00 x 14. 00 inches
• Capacity: toast 6 slices of bread, air fry 3lbs of chicken wings, bake a 12-inch pizza or roast a 4 pound chicken
• Adjustable thermostat with 60-minute timer/auto shutoff, toast shade selector-timer.UC Cubic Feet: 3.249 lb
• Includes: oven rack, baking pan, air fryer rack/basket. Mc cubic feet: 3. 390

With over 15,000 reviews on Amazon, the Cuisinart TOA-60 Toaster Oven makes you feel like a real chef in your very own personal kitchen. The fact that it’s also less expensive than most air fryer toaster ovens of this kind is also a huge plus.

Versatile cooking functions

You can bake, broil, convection bake and broil, warm, toast, air fry, and pre-heat in this toaster oven. It even features different toast shade settings for quick and direct use. There’s an interior light, timer, and proper sturdy parts that keep it handy.

In relation to power efficacy, the toaster oven starts at the ideal keep-warm temperature. It soon increases to the highest cooking temperature of 450-degrees Fahrenheit. It’s fast and efficient in a variety of ways. So if you’re a beginner, this is what you’re looking for to cook food easily and durably.

Functional design

The TOA-60 has a more compact design than its siblings. So you can expect it to take up only some space on the countertop. This is good because even though it’s not as bulky and space-consuming, it can do a lot.

The interior is big enough to fit a 4-pound chicken, 6 slices of bread for toasting, and a twelve inch pizza for grilling. The traditional dials of the TOA-60 are properly maintained and easy to adjust. The digital LCD display makes it easier since it shows all the right settings you need right in front of your eyes. You don’t have to go back and forth to figure out the temperature or the timer.

Having said that, there are a few things that you might need to settle for. Though they are not bad qualities, you can think of them as adjustments, or experiments if you will. The first one is that the timer runs 5 minutes longer than what you set it for.

So if your timer is set for 10 minutes, the cooking will take 15 minutes. So keep this in mind to avoid burning or over-cooking the food. That’s all.

Pros

• Sturdy and non-slip rubber feet.
• Easy and straightforward dial control panel.
• Adjustable and accurate thermostat with auto shut-off.

Cons

• The removable parts are not dishwasher-safe.
• Cleaning the interior is a bit tricky.

6. Ninja dt201 foodi 10-in-1 xl pro air fry digital toaster oven

• Ninja DT201 Foodi 10-in-1 XL Pro Air Fry Digital Countertop Convection Toaster Oven with Dehydrate and Reheat, 1800 Watts, Stainless Steel Finish
• True Surround Convection: Up to 10X the convection power vs. a traditional full-size convection oven for faster, crispier, and juicy results
• Ultimate Versatility: Air Fry, Air Roast, Bake, Whole Roast, Broil, Toast, Bagel, Dehydrate, Reheat, and Pizza, all in one powerful 1800-watt appliance
• Quick Family Meals: 90-second oven preheat time and up to 30% faster cooking than a traditional full-size convection oven
• Extra-Large Countertop Oven Capacity: 2-level even cooking, no rotating required—fit a 5-lb chicken and a sheet pan of vegetables, 2 12-in pizzas, or a 12-lb turkey
• Air Fryer Healthy Meals: Up to 75% less fat when using the Air Fry function vs. traditional deep frying(tested against hand-cut, deep-fried French fries)

This is one of the easiest digital toaster ovens to use. It’s built so impressively sturdily. I got this toaster oven originally for the 90-second oven preheat time. I mean, it’s fast, right? Since I hardly ever have the extra time to preheat the oven first, I’m always amazed by how quiet and fast this one is.

Quick and efficient performance

Using a toaster oven frequently, you can anticipate some delay or lagging for a while. But now with this digital oven, it works in brand new condition for a long time. Coupled with the cooking functions, it’s a delight to use.

I eat toast almost every day. But I do focus on tapping into my creative side to make traditional dishes but with a few changes here and there. And the Ninja really helps me bring all of that together because it’s super-fast.

Compared with the previous convection toaster ovens I’ve used, this one is definitely more powerful in terms of heating. It cooks crispier, faster, and smoother.

Large size

It’s hard not to notice the size of this thing. The interiors are huge! It can fit a 5-pound chicken, two 12-inch pizzas, and the most impressive of them all, a 12-pound turkey!

That’s not all though. The dual rack system stores more and ensures balanced cooking. In other toaster ovens, you’d probably have to rotate the chicken to cook the other side. But not in this one.

Plus, it features three types of fans that promote level cooking. The high-velocity fan which is the main part and the other is the rear heat source. The last part is the best thing: surround air force. The surround air force keeps the hot air circulating to all corners of the oven.

Pros

• Enamel coating for better heat circulation.
• The design is attractive.
• It does look good on any kitchen countertop.
• Quick heat-up time and consistent cooking.
• It gives you access to so many exciting cooking modes.

Cons

• The timer is a bit inaccurate.

Air Fryer Toaster Oven vs Convection Oven – Which is Better?

What makes an air fryer toaster oven unique? Look beyond the basic features like the size and capacity, price and durability to find what works best for you. And I’ve found, from my own personal experience, that one of the ways to find an ideal product is by comparing it with something you think is just as good.

For this article, the debate is between an air fryer toaster oven and a convection oven.

Most people, at some point in their lives, have used or are continuing to use a convection oven. It’s a popular kitchen appliance. One of the first things you buy to make a kitchen homely and useful.

Air fryers, however, are a more modern invention. Even though they, too, use convection heating fans to circulate hot air. Only that they do it in a more robust manner than convection ovens.

Air Fryer + Toaster + Convection Oven = Air Fryer Toaster Oven

From this obvious breakdown you can understand that you’re getting more functionality from a convection oven of this kind. It is equipped with front, rear, and surround circulating fans set at different temperatures.

You’ll get a separate air fryer basket to use for air frying all kinds of food. The most common snack being fries. And thanks to the higher temperature and hot air circulation, you can fry different kinds of potatoes.

The next feature to look at is the toaster. What does a toaster do? It toasts bread for sandwiches, buttered toasts, burritos, and other similar bread recipes. Air fryer toaster ovens are equipped with racks and a crumb tray to make cleaning easy.

Lastly, the convection oven does the job of heating and warm food. But that’s not all. Depending on different temperature settings, you can also roast, grill, dehydrate, bake, and broil.

Convection Oven = Convection Oven

A convection oven is equipped with powerful and consistent heat fans. They increase the temperature of the food to preserve its freshness. But they do a lot more like baking, grilling a pizza, and roasting meat.

A convection oven is great for daily home use. Cooking meals is way faster in a convection oven when you compare it with a conventional oven. And it’s more energy efficient too because it uses less heat.

On the display panel of a convection oven, you’ll find a timer button, temperature dial, and a set of pre-programmed cooking modes. This is great if you want a straightforward and effective oven. It’s in no way a step down from an air fryer toaster oven in terms of performance.

But – hold on a second – would you rather pay for something that does exactly what it’s supposed to do? Or would you prefer paying the same amount for something that does a bit extra?

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is an air fryer toaster oven better than a convection oven?

• It has more heating elements that cooks food faster.
• The fan is 30-50% faster than convection ovens.
• It is paired with extra accessories like air fryer basket, tray, racks, spits, skewers, etc.
• More than 5-8 cooking modes in a single oven. So it’s more space-saving and cost-effective.

Because it’s an air fryer, you get to make delicious recipes in a healthy, oil-free manner. This, even in terms of energy consumption, is more penny-pinching and eco-friendly.

How big is an air fryer toaster oven?

A conventional toaster can hold no more than 2 slices of bread unless you’re buying a really expensive and high-end model. And an air fryer between medium and large capacity can hold no more than 1-2 pounds of fries in its air fryer basket.

In an air fryer toaster oven, however, you can put 4 to 8 slices of bread for toasting. The air fryer basket has a capacity of up to 3 pounds of potato fries. And in terms of food volume for roasting, baking, grilling, etc. you can put 8 to 12 pound turkey.

Even a medium-sized air fryer toaster oven is suitable for 3 people without any fuss. And if you cook only for yourself, it’s a huge advantage because you can prepare meals in advance to save time in the kitchen preparing meals.

Air Fryer Toaster Oven vs Convection Oven – Which is Better?

What makes an air fryer toaster oven unique? Look beyond the basic features like the size and capacity, price and durability to find what works best for you. And I’ve found, from my own personal experience, that one of the ways to find an ideal product is by comparing it with something you think is just as good.

For this article, the debate is between an air fryer toaster oven and a convection oven.

Most people, at some point in their lives, have used or are continuing to use a convection oven. It’s a popular kitchen appliance. One of the first things you buy to make a kitchen homely and useful.

Air fryers, however, are a more modern invention. Even though they, too, use convection heating fans to circulate hot air. Only that they do it in a more robust manner than convection ovens.

Air Fryer + Toaster + Convection Oven = Air Fryer Toaster Oven

From this obvious breakdown you can understand that you’re getting more functionality from a convection oven of this kind. It is equipped with front, rear, and surround circulating fans set at different temperatures.

You’ll get a separate air fryer basket to use for air frying all kinds of food. The most common snack being fries. And thanks to the higher temperature and hot air circulation, you can fry different kinds of potatoes.

The next feature to look at is the toaster. What does a toaster do? It toasts bread for sandwiches, buttered toasts, burritos, and other similar bread recipes. Air fryer toaster ovens are equipped with racks and a crumb tray to make cleaning easy.

Lastly, the convection oven does the job of heating and warm food. But that’s not all. Depending on different temperature settings, you can also roast, grill, dehydrate, bake, and broil.

Convection Oven = Convection Oven

A convection oven is equipped with powerful and consistent heat fans. They increase the temperature of the food to preserve its freshness. But they do a lot more like baking, grilling a pizza, and roasting meat.

A convection oven is great for daily home use. Cooking meals is way faster in a convection oven when you compare it with a conventional oven. And it’s more energy efficient too because it uses less heat.

On the display panel of a convection oven, you’ll find a timer button, temperature dial, and a set of pre-programmed cooking modes. This is great if you want a straightforward and effective oven. It’s in no way a step down from an air fryer toaster oven in terms of performance.

But – hold on a second – would you rather pay for something that does exactly what it’s supposed to do? Or would you prefer paying the same amount for something that does a bit extra?

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is an air fryer toaster oven better than a convection oven?

– It has more heating elements that cooks food faster.
– The fan is 30-50% faster than convection ovens.
– It is paired with extra accessories like air fryer basket, tray, racks, spits, skewers, etc.
– More than 5-8 cooking modes in a single oven. So it’s more space-saving and cost-effective.
– Because it’s an air fryer, you get to make delicious recipes in a healthy, oil-free manner. This, even in terms of energy consumption, is more penny-pinching and eco-friendly.

How big is an air fryer toaster oven?

A conventional toaster can hold no more than 2 slices of bread unless you’re buying a really expensive and high-end model. And an air fryer between medium and large capacity can hold no more than 1-2 pounds of fries in its air fryer basket.

In an air fryer toaster oven, however, you can put 4 to 8 slices of bread for toasting. The air fryer basket has a capacity of up to 3 pounds of potato fries. And in terms of food volume for roasting, baking, grilling, etc. you can put 8 to 12 pound turkey.

Even a medium-sized air fryer toaster oven is suitable for 3 people without any fuss. And if you cook only for yourself, it’s a huge advantage because you can prepare meals in advance to save time in the kitchen preparing meals.

Are atmosphere fryers better compared to toaster ovens?

A normal toaster oven will prepare most dishes with the exact same speed, as a normal oven could require. An atmosphere fryer, on the other hand, can prepare the very same food in approximately half the time, as a result of this strong fan and truth that they have a bigger place inside.

Conclusion

Think about this for a minute. And then YOU TELL ME which is the better choice – an Best Air Fry Toaster Oven or a traditional convection oven? Air fryers make life easier because you can bake the things you previously used to deep fry. Like chicken nuggets, fries, hot wings, and other delicious treats.

And you can do this in a convection oven that also doubles as a toaster. So it’s a space-efficient, budget-friendly, and long-term decision to invest in a high-quality and durable the best rated air fryer for Kitchen Appliance.

See More:

• The Best Air Fryer Consumer Reports of 2021